When Do I Need a Contractor?
With Home Depot and Lowes empowering weekend warriors and DIYers like never before, a question many people ask is, “At what point do I need a contractor for my project?”

It’s a legitimate question–none of us wants to pay more money for something than we have to, and honestly, hiring a general contractor feels unnecessary at times, right? Well, as a general contractor who does remodels and custom homes in
Kuna, Boise, Nampa, Star, Eagle, Middleton, and the surrounding areas, let me give you some unbiased insight on when you need a general contractor.
When You Definitely do Not Need a General Contractor
First, to answer this question effectively, let me start with when you definitely do not need a general contractor:
- Any project that involves one single specialty–for example, I just went and looked at a project in Kuna where the client wanted to “remodel” their bathroom. However, on further inspection, what they really wanted to do was just paint the current bathroom. For situations like these, where you’re “just painting;” “just moving outlets;” “just changing lights;” etc., you definitely do not need a contractor.
- Your project is less than $1000 total. Most likely, if your project falls in this camp, it also falls in the description of number one above. However, even if there are a few items, but your project doesn’t break the $1,000 threshold, you definitely don’t need a general contractor.
- You have an emergency leak/disaster. In these cases, you’re better off calling a disaster cleanup place. They may use a general contractor, or tell you to get bids from a general contractor to repair the damage, but your immediate phone call should be to a disaster clean-up company, not a general contractor.
When it Makes Sense to Hire a General Contractor
Now that we have established when you definitely do not need a general contractor, let me address when it makes sense to hire a general contractor for your home remodel in Kuna and the surrounding areas.
- Your project has more than two areas of expertise involved. Any project that requires plumbing, floors, painting, and electrical is a sure sign you’ll be better off hiring a general contractor.
- You’re new to the area. We have lots of people move in to Kuna, Eagle, Nampa and the Treasure Valley who don’t have connections to local contractors. A good honest general contractor can take care of you and ensure you get the best quality and pricing.
- You’ll have multiple skilled workers on your project during the day while you are at work. Nothing is more frustrating than thinking you and the crews are on the same page only to come home after everyone is gone and the work is done to find that your vision was completely misunderstood.
Within this realm of “when do I need a general contractor” there is an implied question–is it worth hiring a general contractor?
If you hire the right contractor (which we discuss in depth in our other blog posts), then it is most definitely worth it. Here are a few key benefits a general contractor can provide:
- General contractors are like “wholesalers” for local trades people. Even after they charge their contractor fee, you’re likely still getting the work cheaper than if you called the individual trades yourself. For example, I am currently in the process of building a pool house in Eagle that the client wanted to build himself initially. He had bids from all his subcontractors that he needed. When I got involved, I had no idea he had already bid his job out. I submitted my total bid for the project, and even after charging my contractor fee to run the project, I am still saving him over $10,000 on his project!
- General contractors have expertise in a lot of areas to ensure your project is done right. A quick story here–I had a home addition in Eagle that I bid out to the client a year ago. I try not to do more than about 3 projects concurrently, and told the client that, although I got him a bid, it would be about 4 months before I had the bandwidth to fit his project in. He informed me that he had some contacts and could run the project himself. A year later, he called me and asked me to finish the project. Despite his best efforts, he couldn’t tell when a portion of the project was done right, and paid the contractors as they billed him. Then when the next crew came, they couldn’t proceed until specific things were fixed. The project is nearly complete now, and the client no longer has to stress about the quality–that’s what we take care of.
- You don’t know what you don’t know. General contractors have tricks that can save you thousands. I just went through an addition in Kuna where the client wanted some specific layout. However, with a few tweaks, we saved the client thousands of dollars on lumber by fitting the new plans to the existing roof. It wasn’t that the client “wanted” to spend the additional money–they just did what they thought would look good without knowing what things could save them money.
Not every project requires a general contractor. But for the ones that do, you can save money, stress, time, and future headaches by hiring a general contractor.



